Quality workshops realise the importance of correct engine oils, leading Rob Marshall to see how testing provides not just reassurance but also technical support.

Many things have changed in the automotive world in the last few decades but one of the most noticeable is that modern vehicles’ lubricant demands have become even more exacting. Most workshops no longer adopt the ‘That Will Do’ approach to oils and rightly so. Should the oil specification not match the blender’s specification claims, is not changed on time, or becomes contaminated, the mechanical component will suffer – and you might cop the blame. This highlights the importance of testing.
Does it do what it says?
Naturally, oil blenders must be truthful with their claims and testing is a vital part of this. TPS emphasises the vital role internal testing plays to confirm that specified base oils and additive packages have been used correctly and that the finished product meets its target physical, chemical, and performance parameters. Motul agrees, highlighting that manufacturers should be able to demonstrate that their products have been tested appropriately against the specifications and approvals they claim to meet.
Despite this stance, TPS admits that internal controls alone cannot provide the same assurance as independent industry testing and formal OEM approvals. These subject the complete formulation to extensive laboratory and engine testing. The result is objective evidence to confirm that the oil meets the required specification and performance standard. TPS concludes that formal OEM approval therefore remains the clearest benchmark of verified lubricant quality and compliance.
Lubrizol is an organisation that, amongst other things, develops additives for lubricants, including engine oils. Part of the development process is ensuring that additives meet the requirements set out by OEMs, ACEA (European Automobile Manufacturers' Association), and API (American Petroleum Institute). This involves specific industry-standard engine testing requirements. Lubrizol has global testing facilities, analytical testing and research and development laboratories, all of which are accredited and able to run industry-standard testing.
Yet, this is not arbitrary. Lubrizol notes that, in Europe, the framework underpinning specifications and performance is EELQMS (European Engine Lubricant Quality Management System), a quality management system (albeit voluntary) that promotes the development of lubricants that meet technical requirements. This is in addition to internal quality assurance testing that decent oil blenders undertake to ensure that their product is compliant.
Even so, not all blenders are decent. Lubrizol’s own research into ‘The Importance of Testing and OEM Approvals’ has identified that different approval levels of engine oil quality can be linked to a lack of testing. For example, lubricants supported with ‘Suitable For Use’ claims might never have been tested. Inadequate, or incomplete, testing can contribute to engine oils not meeting their claimed standards, particularly where ‘Suitable For Use’ claims are based on limited in-house data rather than the complete required test programme. However, Lubizol reasons that formulation choices, data interpretation, documentation and the accuracy of the claims made are also important factors.
Too good to be true? Testing can tell...
Challenge and check a product’s claims if the price presents an apparent mega bargain. One way of doing this is to ask the supplier to provide Technical Data Sheets to confirm the correct approvals.
Duckhams highlights the proliferation of aftermarket 5W30 ACEA C3 engine oil, even though very few OEMs specify it.
Most of them require additional specifications, such as MB 229.51, BMW LL-04, Volkswagen 504 00, or 507 00. These specifications require many more enhanced tests than the standard C3 specification. Therefore, while 5W30 ACEA C3 is very popular, a generic product is rarely the right choice.

The UK-based VLS comments that, as lubricant blenders assess potential formulation options, they must review the bench and engine test data from their technology and base oil suppliers to ensure that the intended specification claims can be supported. Once this formulation is established, adequate quality control procedures must be in place to monitor key parameters on different batches to ensure consistent product quality. This is because the VLS has been involved in cases, where investigated lubricant blenders have had to improve their testing regimes to bring a product back into compliance.
Picking up dropped balls...
A well-established brand is more likely to have processes in place to minimise mistakes. For instance, Motul highlights
its comprehensive validation process covering formulation development, laboratory analysis, production quality control and performance verification. Testing includes assessing physical and chemical properties, including oxidation stability, wear protection and compatibility with current industry and OEM requirements. Each batch of Quantum oil, supplied by TPS, is subjected to quality-control checks, including verification of key physical and chemical properties, to ensure consistency.
Even so, mistakes can happen. As regular readers know, the VLS investigates lubricants that appear not to meet the claimed technical specifications. Accurate testing is vital to its process, which is why the VLS conducts testing at premises that meet overarching quality standards, such as ISO 17025 for testing and calibration services. In addition, the United Kingdom Accreditation Service (UKAS) accredits every test separately. To ensure impartiality and fairness, results are anonymised, prior to being sent to the Technical Review Panel.
How testing helps you...
Ultimately, you are responsible for your customers’ cars. Should you use an incorrect, or incompatible oil, you would be liable. As Duckhams attests, lubricant testing provides not only insights into properties such as viscosity, high- temperature performance, shear properties, and levels of sulphated ash, phosphorus, and sulphur, but also valuable insight into the performance and health of a mechanical component. Having an oil tested, therefore, can reveal how and why the component failed. Garages can find such information useful, especially when gathering evidence to defend a claim.
Quality lubricant suppliers, such as Duckhams, can organise testing for you. The Motul Oil Analysis Kit allows workshops and operators to submit a used oil sample for laboratory analysis and receive a detailed report on lubricant condition and equipment health. It costs £44 inclusive of VAT and covers not just engines but also transmissions. TPS customers can access its oil testing product support for no fee.
Ultimately, we rely on brand ethics to ensure that the original formulations have been tested and quality control testing continues over the production run. Yet, garages should also be aware that used oil testing has value both as a means of gathering evidence but also, potentially, as an extra service that can be offered to technically-interested customers.
Supplementary Additives...
Additives that are dosed into oil range from flushes, cleaners, fortifiers and those that provide temporary repair assistance. Many oil blenders advise against using them, reasoning that they could upset the delicate chemistry balance within the oil blend. The VLS advises that the additives an engine needs should be formulated into the lubricant already to meet the vehicle's specification, therefore, no extra ‘help’ should be needed.
Another challenge is that supplementary additives do not have to meet set technical standards, so their effectiveness can vary widely. Another issue is that OEMs tend not to endorse them officially, even though some main dealers use them in their workshops.
Many independent garages also have positive experiences using quality additives, either as part of routine maintenance (such as an oil flush), to assist with severe driving conditions (such as a DPF regeneration- assisting fuel additive), or to delay mechanical replacement (such as a stop-leak seal-swell product).
The problem is, who do you trust?
Kalimex believes testing helps you find an answer. Its famous K-Seal product, for instance, is the only product of its type to be university-tested and shown to conform with ASTM D3147. This globally recognised standard proves that K-Seal plugs leaks in areas including the radiator, cylinder head and gasket, block, heater matrix and water pump, without blocking even the narrowest waterways in the cooling system.

Avoiding a race to the bottom...
Ultimately, with corporates and the public tightening their belts, quality lubricant blenders worry that cost pressures are compromising quality. TPS and Lubrizol acknowledge the high costs of testing and meeting OEM standards, which is why they advise you to steer clear of products that use descriptions such as “meets”, “recommended for” or “suitable for use”, and to check whether (or not) the product carries the specific OEM approval required for the application.
Motul acknowledges that, while the lubricant market is highly competitive and there will always be different price levels, workshops should look not only for evidence of technical validation and recognised approvals but also for robust quality control processes and strong technical support. It elaborates that, as engine designs become more sophisticated, the margin for error reduces. Using a lubricant simply because it is the cheapest creates risks, should it be unsuitable for the application, or is unable to meet the required specification throughout its service life.
Duckhams concurs, highlighting that premium engine oil is produced from high-quality materials in a formulation proven through multi-million-pound testing. Its base oil is likely to be a more refined Group 2 or Group 3, whereas cheaper alternatives are more likely to employ Group 1, or mineral-based, oils from unreliable sources. Furthermore, the additives are unlikely to have been through full development or testing. With more oil brands entering the market, Duckhams acknowledges that making the right choice is becoming even harder for garages. Its final advice is that, while workshops should seek cost efficiencies, lubricants should not be compromised.
CDTI: Finding the frauds...
Companies also use scientific testing to weed out unfair competition. While quality firms welcome healthy competition, they insist that this must be on an even playing field. A typical example is the work that CDTi has undertaken in the fuel-borne (‘Eolys’) catalyst market over the last thirty years. These systems were pioneered by the OEM formerly known as PSA, now Stellantis, and used by a variety of OEMs, including Ford, Mazda and Volvo.
CDTi expertise extends to testing and development services for other firms, specialising in catalyst-based emission control products. Internal investigations into competing products with also impossibly low prices have uncovered many aftermarket on-board dosing additives containing very little costly active ingredients that are needed to prevent DPFs from blocking. The resultant more frequent, but less effective, regenerations not only reduce fuel economy but also shorten DPF life. In short, such cheap products came with extra long-term costs.